Even though this is called Pear Honey, there's no honey in this recipe. I'm not sure where it originated, but judging from the number of older people who remember their grandparents making it, I think this recipe goes back a few generations. I believe it's called "honey" because of it's silky-smooth texture and nectar-like taste, but your guess is as good as mine.
I did quite a bit of research in old cookbooks and on the internet while testing this recipe. All of the recipes called for varying amounts of pears, and always canned pineapple, not fresh. I prefer Bartletts for this, but you could try other pears if you so desire. If you don't want to make such a large batch, cut the recipe in half, using a small pineapple, or half of a large one.
While the ingredients list is short and the directions appear simple, this is a real winner. It's amazing to me that with a bit of skill and plenty of heat, 4 common ingredients can be turned into something so lusciously delicious.
Makes ~12 half pints
Note: Prepare canning jars and keep hot until ready to use; prepare lids according to the manufacturer's instructions. (If macerating the fruit & sugar mixture overnight, you will want to wait until the next day to prepare the jars.)
1.) Peel, core and cut pineapple into chunks, trying to retain as much juice as possible and place chunks and any juice into a large bowl. (I cut chunks on a cutting board with an outer groove that collects the juice.)
2.) Cut the lemons in half and squeeze their juice over pineapple in bowl. (Or add bottled lemon juice.)
3.) Peel, core and cut pears into chunks, and add them to the pineapple & lemon juice. You should have approximately 12-14 cups of chopped fruit.
4.) Add sugar to the fruit mixutre, stir well to combine and cover. Let it sit on the counter at least one hour, but preferably 8 hours, or even overnight. The longer it sits, the more juices will be pulled from the fruit, forming a wonderful syrup in the bowl.
5.) After letting the mixture sit the desired time, stir mixture together well, scraping any sugar that might have collected on the bottom of the bowl.
6.) Place pineapple/pear mixture in a heavy-bottomed non-reactive pan (don't use aluminum or cast iron). Bring to a boil over medium high heat and cook for about 20 minutes, stirring occasionally to prevent the fruit from sticking to the bottom of the pan. Stir the fruit gently while cooking to reduce foaming.
7.) After about 20 minutes the fruit should be softening and you can use an immersion blender or potato masher periodically mash the chunks and create a smooth texture.
8.) Boil for 5-15 more minutes, stirring, until the jam either thickens to your liking or until it reaches 220 degrees on a candy thermometer. You can also use the sheeting test, as shown in my blog post. (Link at bottom of recipe.)
9.) Ladle jam into clean hot jars, leaving 1/4" headspace, wipe rims spotlessly clean with a damp paper towel and place a lid on top of jar. Next, screw a band onto the jar until it's "fingertip-tight".
10.) Process for 10* minutes in a Boiling Water Bath. (Time given is for sea level.)
11.) Turn kettle off and let jars rest in kettle for 5 more minutes.
12.) Remove jars from kettle using jar-lifter tongs, and gently set aside to cool on the counter, on a kitchen towel, in a draft-free place.
13.) Let rest for 24 hours, then check jars for a proper seal before storing.
14.) If jars lid seals it will easily keep for one year in a cool, dark place. If jar doesn't seal, place it in your refrigerator and eat within 3 months, and within one month after opening.
Important: Check lids for a proper seal by pressing down on the middle of the lid with a finger or thumb. If the lid stays down, it is sealed and will easily keep for up to one year in a cool dark place. If the lid springs up when you release your finger, the lid is not properly sealed.
*0-1000 ft: process 10 minutes
1,001-6,000 ft: process 15 minutes
Above 6,000 ft: process 20 minutes
*Check lids for a proper seal by pressing down on the middle of the lid with a finger or thumb. If the lid stays down, it is sealed and will easily keep for up to one year in a cool dark place. If the lid springs up when you release your finger, the lid is not properly sealed.